audio by title can a deaf mute count in a minyan receive an aliya - v3 2

Can a deaf mute count in a Minyan & receive an Aliya - v3 #2 by R' Aaron Cohen


17:32 minutes (3.01 MB)

Rav Oshry presents a heart-wrenching question posed by R’ Moshe ben R’ Aryeh, who davened in Rav Oshry’s Bais Medrash. While on a work detail, he looked for potatoes and vegetables growing in the fields to give some nourishment to the starving Jews working with him. The Germans caught and beat him mercilessly, causing him to lose his hearing and speech faculties. He maintained his cognitive abilities. Could he be counted in a Minyan? Could he receive an Aliya to the Torah?